June 22nd, 2012
The Interstate Highway System is crucial to American travel, commerce and civil defense. However, in recent years the Highway Trust Fund (HTF), which is responsible for maintaining the highway system, has been underfunded. With the HTF in peril of going broke, constructing new toll road systems should not be ruled out, according to a recent report from a University of Missouri engineer.
“The issue to focus on is how to fund our vital transportation system, as opposed to choosing sides in a pro-toll versus anti-toll debate,” said Carlos Sun, associate professor of civil and environmental engineering in the MU College of Engineering. “Truck drivers and travelers may choose to take one route over another if it means a safer ride with less wear on their vehicles, even if they have to pay a toll. For example, in Missouri, Interstate 70 competes with I-90 and I-40 in other states. Well-maintained toll roads could capture revenue for Missouri’s economy from out-of-state truckers and travelers, even if they don’t buy gas or other products in the state.”
Sun documented the challenges of using toll roads in Missouri in a recent legal review. In his review, he discussed how a 1939 report, “Toll Roads and Free Roads,” influenced national legislation to favor free roads. Although some states, such as California, have since rejected the findings of that report and implemented toll road systems, Missouri has not. Sun examined a 1969 Missouri Supreme Court decision, Pohl v. State Highway Commission, which blocked the construction of toll roads in Missouri. The court justified the decision by suggesting toll roads would siphon funds from free roadway projects. The ruling itself was not related to a specific project, but created a legal question affecting future toll road projects.
“The situation has changed since 1939 and 1969,” Sun said. “Early planners hadn’t considered the tremendous volume of traffic that now flows over American highways and the subsequently higher costs of maintaining those roadways. The reality of the situation now is that the HTF may go broke as the cost of repairing bridges and roads outpaces fuel tax revenues.”
Toll roads also can result in a more equitable distribution of costs, according to Sun’s analysis, since only people who use them pay. Also, drivers of heavier vehicles that cause more wear on the road could pay proportionally to their impact.
The 1939 report argued that toll roads make travel more difficult for the poor. To the contrary, Sun noted that in California, funds from toll roads have been used to improve public transit systems, which enabled low-income families to live in higher quality, more affordable housing further from city centers.
Sun’s legal review was published in the Kansas Journal of Law and Public Policy.